Thieves made off with board games and a large number of rare Digimon trading cards.
A man allegedly returned around 1.15 pm on the same day and attempted to sell the stolen cards back to the store.
Staff alerted police, who were then led to a nearby house where they found the stolen goods.
Police have charged two 41-year-old men, two 28-year-old men, a 30-year-old woman, and are looking for a sixth, over the alleged theft.
Join Tom Tilley with regular rotating co-hosts Jan Fran, Annika Smethurst and Jamila Rizvi on The Briefing, Monday - Saturday, for the day's headlines and breaking news as well as hot topics and interviews. Available on Listnr.